Search:  
 for 

 Back to your local site:
 


Related sites

Knight Ridder Washington Bureau: Making sense of Washington and the world.

Herald.com.
HERALD BLOGS


My blogroll:
ResourceShelf
Docuticker
TheScoop
Romenesko
Morning Meeting
New Media Musings
IDigAnswers
J-Log
LibLog
Subterranean Homepage News
Guardian Newsblog
Cursor
E-Media Tidbits
EJournal
Buzz Machine
Cyberjournalist
First Draft
Press Think
Newsliblog

Achenblog
Dave Barry
Shifted Librarian
Library Stuff
Doc Searls
Dan Bricklin
Scripting News
Searchblog
Boing Boing
Blandiose
Memeorandum
Discourse.net
Metafilter
Florida Blog
Florida Politics.

More Weblogs



Knight Ridder election blogs
  • Hot off the Trail
  • Life of the Parties
  • Ozblog
  • Ohioblog
  • Campaign Extra!
  • Infomaniac: WeBlog
  • Free-Fire Zone
  • Debate This!


  • Knight Ridder's Politics Blogroll
  • Michael Froomkin, UM law prof
  • Jay Rosen's PressThink
  • ConventionBloggers
  • Yahoo's Blog Roundup
  • Feedster's Politics Page
  • Technorati Election Watch
  • The Tank's RNC Bloggers
  • Romenesko
  • CyberJournalist
  • Lost Remote
  • TV Newser
  • Blogging of the President
  • Reason's convention blog
  • Tapped
  • Nat. Review's The Corner
  • The Command Post
  • Daily Kos
  • Campaign Desk
  • Scripting News
  • Roger L. Simon
  • Matt Welch
  • KausFiles
  • ABC's The Note
  • Tacitus
  • Power Line
  • Blogs for Bush
  • OxBlog
  • Talk Left
  • Political Wire
  • Glenn Reynolds: Instapundit
  • Jeff Jarvis: Buzzmachine
  • Talking Points Memo
  • Betsy's Page




  • Infomaniac: WeBlog



    Overheard on the Web, and other Web links
    From The Herald's Research Editor


    Wednesday, January 12, 2005

    'Rathergate', continued... 

    Since the CBS News independent panel report (on the 60 minutes story on GW Bush's military service) came out, it's been talked over and over (see what comes up on it if you search blogs in Technorati, e.g., or check out the links in Ratherbiased.com). But if you want to read the report yourself, it's available online: CBS Report in PDF format. It's quite a long document, over 200 pages, but definitely worth a read, if only to match it to the claims being made. I've heard of radio reports claiming it cofirms that the documents reported on in the original story were definitely fabricated. That's way beyond the conclusions of this report, but it does say this about the documents:
      "First, in many instances, the content of the Killian documents does not
      mesh well substantively with the official Bush records. Second, the Killian documents vary in significant ways from the standard format and jargon of documents issued by the 147th Fighter Interceptor Group in the early 1970s. Thus, the Panel believes that there remain substantial questions regarding the authenticity of the Killian documents. The Panel believes that careful reporting prior to airing the Segment should have identified these questions and, at a minimum, should have delayed the broadcast so that more reporting could be conducted."

    The discrepancies in the documents are listed, and they concern more than just a question of typefaces proving when the document was first printed.

    posted by liz at 10:10 AM
    Comments: Post a Comment



    Elisabeth Donovan


    Elisabeth (Liz) Donovan was a Herald librarian for 10 years, and Research Editor for 13 years. She came to The Herald in 1981, following several years at the Washington Post. She started blogging in 2000, with a news research blog, followed by the blog at Herald.com in 2003. A frequent speaker and writer on news research, she was honored in 2004 by the News Division of the Special Libraries Association for her contributions to the field.


     Latest posts

       •  Yesterday's News
       •  What are they thinking?
       •  Deja vu
       •  Remember the election?
       •  Bloggers in Miami
       •  How's that resolution going?
       •  The president's brother
       •  Rathergate/Bloggergate
       •  It's our freedom
       •  Lost on the beach


     Archives
       •  July 1990
       •  October 2004
       •  November 2004
       •  December 2004
       •  January 2005
       •  February 2005
       •  March 2005
       •  April 2005
       •  May 2005
       •  June 2005
       •  July 2005
       •  August 2005
       •  July 2006

    Old blog (WeBlog at Herald.com, 7/2003-10/2004)    •  Back to the main page




    Florida Blogs:
  • Abstract Appeal
  • Babalu Blog (from Miami)
  • Bark Bark Woof Woof (Miami)
  • Buzz Bruggerman
  • Rogers Cadenhead
  • Coconut Grove Grapevine
  • Critical Miami
  • Cuban-American Pundits
  • Discourse.net UM law prof Michael Froomkin
  • The Disney Blog
  • Drudge (Miami Beach)
  • Eye of the Storm (Tallahassee)
  • Florida Blog
  • Florida Cracker
  • Florida Politics
  • Florida News
  • The Garden's Gift (Tampa area)
  • Hatless (from Broward)
  • Hidden City (from Miami)
  • An Imperfect Equilibrium (Perry)
  • Interstate4Jamming (Central FL)
  • Paperfrog
  • Paxety
  • Peer Review (Tallahassee)
  • Pensacola Beach Blog
  • The Pensito Review (St. Augustine)
  • ReidBlog (South Florida)
  • Sharkbitten
  • Somewhere on A1A
  • South of the Suwanee
  • Sticks of Fire(Tampa)
  • Taming of the Band-Aid (Naples)
  • The 26th Parallel (Miami)